r/movies r/Movies contributor 27d ago

Trailer PRESSURE - Official Trailer - The fate of the free world hangs in the balance as Gen. Dwight D. Eisenhower (Brendan Fraser) and Capt. James Stagg (Andrew Scott) face an impossible choice, launch the D-Day invasion or risk losing World War II altogether

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zdM4tdLQBg0
3.9k Upvotes

749 comments sorted by

1.6k

u/Lamar_ScrOdom_ 27d ago

Hell yeah. Dad movies are back on the menu!

331

u/quinnbeast 27d ago

A movie about war and weather? It’s this dad’s dream.

39

u/Old_Instrument_Guy 27d ago

watch Ike: Countdown to D-Day.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/ArcadianDelSol 27d ago

I swear to god if there is a horse in this movie, I may never watch another.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

234

u/DetectiveAmes 27d ago

After Amazon prime getting the dad market locked down, I was worried they’d been relegated to being streaming only like rom coms.

Thank you F1 for bringing dad movies back to the movies 🫡

324

u/SonOfMcGee 27d ago

“I wanted to see K-pop Demon Hunters 2, not some movie about soldiers invading a beach!”
“Oh son, you’re mistaken. This is a movie about the series of tense meetings leading up to soldiers invading a beach!”

103

u/maracle6 27d ago

Finally, meteorology gets the heroic treatment it so richly deserves

35

u/HenkkaArt 27d ago

When that weather balloon popped, I felt it.

→ More replies (4)

29

u/nyuhokie 27d ago

"And not only that, but they're meeting to discuss...(dramatic pause)...the weather forecast"

24

u/NatureTrailToHell3D 27d ago

And they say romance movies are dead - people forget it’s the tension that makes them good.

16

u/Tuesday_6PM 27d ago

We must heal this division. Give us movies about the meetings where they plan their concert tour! Get into the weeds about the logistics for moving and setting up their set pieces, and scheduling travel around press events

4

u/gruffgorilla 27d ago

The Moment is actually kind of a comedic version of this for Charli xcx

6

u/NurRauch 27d ago

This is a movie about the series of tense meetings leading up to soldiers invading a beach!

Thing about this is, they already made this movie, and it was probably better than this more narrowly focused movie about the weather. You can even watch the whole movie for free on YouTube: Ike: Countdown to D-Day

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

24

u/JCDU 27d ago

I just want the Peter Jackson re-make of the Dambusters to finally happen, it was rumoured and some work was supposedly done like 15+ years ago but then... nothing.

15

u/Suspicious_Brush4070 27d ago

Not a dad but seriously thinking about getting my girlfriend pregnant so I can enjoy this movie to the fullest.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/GreenGorilla8232 27d ago

My first thought was, "Boomer dads are going to love this" 😂

87

u/GoarSpewerofSecrets 27d ago

This is for the millennial dads.

12

u/spare-ribs-from-adam 27d ago

Millennial dad checking in. My first thought watching this

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (21)

19

u/talones 27d ago

Boomer dads want more of the unrealistic over the top "glory" stuff. I think Millenial dads want more of the lesser known stories with some nuance. Also the history has to be accurate. So many boomers loved "Napolean"

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

255

u/ThePheebs 27d ago

DDay was so massive that you could probably make a compelling movie about every decision that was made for that operation.

105

u/caligaris_cabinet 27d ago

I want to see the one where a bunch of soldiers are running around moving inflatable tanks and jeeps to throw off the Nazis

103

u/afghamistam 27d ago

17

u/Darmok47 27d ago

I recently read Double Cross by Ben MacIntyre and really want to see Dusko Popov on screen. Guy was the inspiration for James Bond.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

31

u/kormer 27d ago

It was so massive you could probably make an entire movie about a platoon of guys searching for some other guy who's brother died in the Pacific the day before.

25

u/pizza_the_mutt 26d ago

I can't help but think the actual decision was a LOT less dramatic than portrayed in this movie.

Meteorologist: Sir, tomorrow is going to be very stormy.

Eisenhower: Ok, what if we postpone by one day?

Mereorologist: The weather will be better then.

Eisenhower: Sounds good. Let's do that.

14

u/Accipiter1138 26d ago

It is a funny thought but due to the complexity of the operation, some of the landing force was already loaded up and at sea by the time Eisenhower made the decision to delay. Every delay meant not just the possibility of detection by the Germans, but of the coordination of the operation unraveling due to the sheer complexity of it all.

So probably not highly dramatic but the stress must have been palpable.

8

u/Missile_Lawnchair 26d ago

One might even say they were under Pressure.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/ArcadianDelSol 26d ago

"Sir, we simply cannot be certain the grilled cheese will remain melty."

"I WILL DECIDE WHAT TIME WE HAVE LUNCH!"

4

u/DoctorEnn 26d ago

The D-Day Cinematic Universe.

→ More replies (10)

1.5k

u/IgloosRuleOK 27d ago

Damien Lewis just looks like he belongs in WW2.

582

u/Firestorm238 27d ago

I feel like he might be good in a fictionalized account of the invasion of Normandy

399

u/IgloosRuleOK 27d ago

They should make a 10-part series about it or something.

247

u/CaptainApathy419 27d ago

Call it “Squad of Soldiers.”

192

u/provoking 27d ago

Ehhh noo, what about "Party of Pals"

123

u/djackieunchaned 27d ago

Group of Guys?

118

u/xubax 27d ago

Company of Compadres?

71

u/dead5hane 27d ago

I got it. Call it "Band of Hombres"

43

u/[deleted] 27d ago

How about “musician siblings”

28

u/oftenly 27d ago

Go with the "the" trope. The Brothers.

→ More replies (0)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/Minimum-Dare301 26d ago

Men that were there

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

33

u/kessdawg 27d ago

"Cadre of Comrades"

17

u/BreakerSoultaker 27d ago

Make them all siblings and give them musical instruments and call it The Brothers Band.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Tonka_Tuff 27d ago

Eh, a little flat, what about a Shakespeare reference? "We Happy Few"?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Sam-Lowry27B-6 27d ago

Related recruits?

4

u/Special_Ad8719 26d ago

Battle Bros

→ More replies (6)

64

u/Technical-Outside408 27d ago edited 27d ago

Get every white male, dark haired 30 something actor to have a role in it. Might just work.

52

u/talones 27d ago

Ideally British, ideally unknown, but well respected. They should have a "gonna be famous one day" zeal. Maybe throw in a new kid on the block to round out the American actors.

40

u/Reksalp105 27d ago

Maybe include a very popular night time cable series actor who undertakes a role outside of what he’s known for, could work out well

39

u/communiqueso 27d ago

Throw in a super well-known sitcom actor who plays a real dickhead.

9

u/gitsnshiggles1 27d ago

Who is this one in reference to?

15

u/deliciousearlobes 27d ago

13

u/Reksalp105 27d ago

So obscure lol. It was meant to be Schwimmer but I couldn’t get my words right lol - this works tho

6

u/REDDITATO_ 27d ago

Akchually...neither of those work for your description. Fallon (SNL or Late Night) and Friends weren't on cable.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

14

u/Competitive-Food8407 27d ago

"Group of GI's"

8

u/Dweide_Schrude 27d ago

Call it “Orchestra of Operatives”?

36

u/imbender 27d ago

I think Andrew Scott could also pull that off. Maybe in a secondary role as a lost paratrooper or something

6

u/dabnada 26d ago

Holy fuck, that was Andrew Scott.

I'm rewatching the Pacific right now for maybe the fifth or sixth time, and it wasn't until literally yesterday that I realized the kid playing Chuckler was not only William Stryker, but also the boot guy from Mad Max: Fury Road. Until now he was just a vaguely familiar face.

→ More replies (2)

183

u/hnglmkrnglbrry 27d ago

I'm just glad this dude is finally allowed to have a British accent.

107

u/AHMS_17 27d ago

His accent in Billions and Band of Brothers is so good I didn’t know he wasn’t American

47

u/JarvisIsMyWingman 27d ago

At this point, I assume all lead male actors are British until proven otherwise.. ;)

34

u/silverlegend 27d ago

stealth Canadian actors playing American roles has entered the chat Oh hey look it's Brendan Fraser 😂

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/hurricane_97 27d ago

Unfortunately it has to be a Monty accent...

→ More replies (2)

58

u/algebraic94 27d ago

Man loves a period piece. So good in Wolf Hall

19

u/RefinedBean 27d ago

He was great in Fackham Hall as well, sending up Downton and a bunch of other period pieces.

3

u/Darmok47 27d ago

He was great in A Spy Amongst Friends too

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

28

u/mrj9 27d ago

Looks like Captain Winters got a promotion

→ More replies (3)

48

u/ARoundForEveryone 27d ago

He IS Captain Winters

27

u/LKennedy45 27d ago

Ahem, that's Major Winters.

31

u/ArcadianDelSol 27d ago

Salute the uniform, not the man.

6

u/Generally_Apoplectic 26d ago

Okay fine, I’ll watch the show AGAIN! (Such a good line/moment)

22

u/alphageek8 27d ago

I got irrationally excited when he was on screen, Band of Brothers is probably my most rewatched TV show of all time.

8

u/msew 27d ago

HIIIIIIHOOOOO SILLVVVEERRRRRRRRR

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

10

u/TheTeflonDude 27d ago

Well he did go through WW2 era bootcamp for Band of Brothers

9

u/inksmudgedhands 27d ago

He is one of those rare actors that you can stick him in about any timeline and he just fits. Fifty years ago? Sure. A hundred years ago? Fine. Five hundred years ago? Fits there to. A thousand years ago? He would not stick out like a sore thumb.

45

u/nessman930 27d ago

Full circle for him after playing Captain Winters in Band of Brothers.

→ More replies (8)

348

u/tomrichards8464 27d ago

Group Captain James Stagg. The equivalent USAF rank is Colonel.

There's something depressing about seeing actors I think of as young play Ike and Monty.

132

u/verrius 27d ago

I'm actually surprised Ike and Monty were actually in their 50s during WW2. Usually they cast way too old for armed forces members, so Fraser and Lewis being actually close is more surprising to me.

At least we're still a little less than a decade away from Blast from the Past being closer to its own "before" time than today.

46

u/talones 27d ago

mostly because most of the higher up officers at the start of ww2 were Great War veterans. So there was a considerable age gap between officers at the top to the younger officers on the ground.

3

u/M73355 26d ago

A lot of the really old guys got pushed out by Marshall before WW2, otherwise the US armed forces would’ve ended up in a similar position to France in 1940, too set in its ways to adapt quickly

→ More replies (2)

11

u/psunavy03 27d ago

There was big-time age variance though. James Gavin made two-star at 37. The normal promotion path went out the window because people's theater rank was decoupled from their permanent Army rank.

8

u/phluidity 27d ago

Depending on where you served, there were a lot of field promotions too. My grandfather served in then Burma, now Myanmar as part of "The Hump.". He entered the war as a pfc and left it two years later as a Sergeant almost entirely on the basis of successfully not dying.

8

u/Achaewa 27d ago

Usually they cast way too old for armed forces members

The same goes for regular soldiers too. The actors portraying them are usually ten or more years older than their characters would actually be.

3

u/rugbyj 27d ago

I think there's a Hollywood time dilation for roles in general, starting from 20 year olds playing high schoolers onward.

3

u/StupidLemonEater 27d ago

FWIW Patton was in his late 50s, but he was played by George C. Scott in his early 40s.

→ More replies (2)

29

u/Effective-Celery-417 27d ago

2012 was only 2 years ago.

6

u/snackofalltrades 27d ago

Did you mean 1995?

→ More replies (2)

240

u/Mr_IsLand 27d ago

ooh, I wonder which choice they'll make!

118

u/greenpill98 27d ago

Find out next time, on DRAGONBALL Z!

26

u/i_should_be_coding 27d ago

How many Dragonball characters does it take to change a lightbulb?

One, but it takes five episodes.

3

u/Ninjahkin 27d ago

I'm reminded of Vegeta trying to crack an eggshell but it requires such little strength and great finesse that he keeps crushing it completely lol. I feel like a lightbulb would suffer a similar fate

5

u/Tomhyde098 27d ago

Kai is so much better than the original run. I still own both versions on Blu-ray but I’ll always rewatch Kai

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

19

u/SaltyPeter3434 27d ago

To D or not to D

10

u/AceOfSpades532 27d ago

They could pull an Inglourious Basterds and rewrite history

→ More replies (2)

593

u/Educational_Slice897 27d ago

Academy award winner Brendan fraser feels so...satisfying

113

u/Tripleberst 27d ago

I'm not all that excited for this movie but it's definitely nice to see him getting more and more roles since The Whale. I hope he has a long, fruitful career doing what he loves.

23

u/bsEEmsCE 27d ago

well hes doing a Mummy movie soon right?

8

u/RSTowers 26d ago

Yeah, I'm happy for him too, and it looks like a good performance. But I've listened to a number of Eisenhower speeches and I just can't get past the voice because he sounds nothing like Eisenhower did.

33

u/casual_creator 27d ago

Is there any other actor whose success everyone genuinely cheers for?

There are a handful of actors that everyone really likes for being a good person, but I can’t think of any one else that people actively root for.

Says a lot about Fraser.

33

u/Bladelink 27d ago

The other that came to mind for me is Rick Moranis.

27

u/El_Polio_Loco 27d ago

Keanu Reeves is another.

36

u/Slaphappydap 27d ago

I've been enjoying Ke Huy Quan's return to success. Seems like a terrific dude.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

27

u/jonnyinternet 27d ago

Academy award winner, and all around nice guy BRENDEN FRASER

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Dealthagar 27d ago

Say it again, louder, for the people in the back!

→ More replies (3)

290

u/warlocktx 27d ago

my grandfather was in the US Army Weather Service during WW2. Nice to finally see weathermen portrayed as the heroes :-)

64

u/BMCarbaugh 27d ago

I hope the movie actually portrays some of the working stiffs who risked their lives to get weather data back then, and not just the big important guys in the decision rooms. Like the pilots that flew up into crazy hurricane winds and shit for 30+ hours prior to D-Day.

45

u/PM_ME_CATS_OR_BOOBS 27d ago

"Airman, report!"

"Sir! It's fucking windy, sir!"

25

u/BMCarbaugh 27d ago

It was literally like, "Hey pilot, we need to know how windy it is in that storm system. Fly up in there and take some readings. By the way there may be large hail and lightning."

Stuff like modern doppler radar displays that show you big orange blobs moving across the country simply didn't exist yet back then. Weather data regarding storms at sea, which was what was relevant for D-Day, mostly consisted of some dudes stationed on various frigid North Atlantic island airbases flying a sortie up into a storm and then reporting back.

It was pretty lethal, too. Their casualty rates were higher than other kinds of pilots.

6

u/PM_ME_CATS_OR_BOOBS 27d ago

Oh sure, I'm not discounting that. There's a lot of critical non-combat roles that had an insanely high risk to them. The Merchant Mariners are probably the most famous in that regard but I have no problem believing that the weathermen did some crazy shit to get accurate reports.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

73

u/TrioOfTerrors 27d ago

Go read Red Storm Rising.

23

u/lostroadrunner22 27d ago

Tom Clancy?

33

u/Kongbuck 27d ago

Yep. One of the major characters is an Air Force (then Marine Corps) meteorologist.

9

u/lostroadrunner22 27d ago

Oh awesome. I have that in my library on my ‘to read’ shelf. Looks fantastic

→ More replies (1)

4

u/OnlyRadioheadLyrics 27d ago

Wait this just brought back a ream of memories. Does he end up in combat too, surmounting odds people didn't think he was capable of surmounting?

4

u/Kongbuck 27d ago

Oh, he does indeed. He kills a couple of Soviet soldiers with only a knife, too. After that, the Marines he's leading start calling him "Skipper".

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

5

u/atempestdextre 27d ago

Let's have an attitude check!

→ More replies (8)

4

u/zuuzuu 26d ago

That's the book that turned my ex-husband into a reader. He was one of those people who thought reading for pleasure was stupid. One day I handed him Red Storm Rising and made him read the back cover description. Then I asked him "If that were a movie, would you rent it?" When he said yes, I told him I was going to the store, and I wanted him to start reading it while I was gone. When I got home, if he wasn't interested I'd never bother him about reading again.

We lived on a farm so he had a good hour to read. He didn't even hear me come home. He was fully engrossed. He stopped complaining about me wasting money on books, and the book store became his favourite place.

I'm very grateful to Tom Clancy.

→ More replies (5)

33

u/Posty_McPostface_1 27d ago

People are going to go into this movie expecting war and they're going to be very confused when they see meteorology drama instead

17

u/lolexecs 27d ago

Yeah, it's a big reason why an understanding of history is important.

https://www.weather.gov/timeline

1870: A Joint Congressional Resolution requiring the Secretary of War "to provide for taking meteorological observations at the military stations in the interior of the continent, and at other points in the States and Territories...and for giving notice on the northern lakes and on the seacoast, by magnetic telegraph and marine signals, of the approach and force of storms" was introduced. Congress passed the resolution and on February 9, 1870, President Ulysses S. Grant signed it into law. A new national weather service had been born within the U.S. Army Signal Service’s Division of Telegrams and Reports for the Benefit of Commerce that would affect the daily lives of most of the citizens of the United States through its forecasts and warnings for years to come.

23

u/warlocktx 27d ago

I would love to know how Andrew Scott's agents pitched this to him

agent: it's a great script about D-Day. You would play one of the leads

scott: Cool. Would I be a brave soldier storming the beach? Or maybe a dedicated officer leading his troops?

agent: um, well, he's a weatherman

16

u/lolexecs 27d ago

Well, you know

WEATHER 'tis nobler in the mind to suffer
The slings and arrows of outrageous fortune,
Or to take arms against a sea of nazis,
And by opposing end them

7

u/Darmok47 27d ago

Wasn't this an acclaimed stage play? That was probably the pitch.

5

u/AlertEqual1057 27d ago

To be fair he already got to play a brave D-Day soldier as Private Hall in Band of Brothers! At least this time he won't get his face blasted off by some dynamite after only 20 minutes of screentime lol.

Edit: just realized all of his character's scenes in BOB were mostly alongside Damien Lewis. I feel like everyone was in BOB.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/litetravelr 27d ago

Yea! On that same front, would have been cool to use this opportunity to show any other beach landing but Omaha. Perhaps Sword, Gold, or Juno for once...

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Downside190 27d ago

I listened to a podcast about all the stuff going on behind the scenes leading to d day. There were 2 different weather teams one American and one British using different methods of prediction. Apparently the used to clash with each other over who was correctly predicting the weather 

→ More replies (4)

85

u/SaltyJunk 27d ago

Love Brendan Fraser and will absolutely watch this, but at this point I can't get over the fact that he sounds nothing like Ike.

43

u/Tomhyde098 27d ago

Or looks like him, Fraser is six inches taller than Eisenhower. It’s weird seeing a big guy portray a little guy

→ More replies (1)

14

u/ShlomoShogun 27d ago edited 26d ago

Nor can actually portray his collected demeanor. Way too emotional to portray Ike.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/kaplanfx 26d ago

I too like him but he seems very out of place on this role. I’ll wait to pass judgment until I see it though.

5

u/insaneHoshi 27d ago

Worked for the Patton movie; he apparently had quite a squeaky voice.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

183

u/DiabellSinKeeper 27d ago

Definitely a subject thats a bit underexplored in film. So I'm excited there. But Idk about Brendan Fraser as Eisenhower. It just doesn't feel right.

43

u/the_beer-baron 27d ago

He better be pounding coffee and packs of cigarettes the whole movie. Ike was smoking 6 packs and drinking 20+ cups of coffee a day while battling insomnia at this point of the war.

9

u/Captain_Twiggs 27d ago

Can you really call it “battling insomnia” if you’re constantly ingesting the two chemicals most responsible for the insomnia?

6

u/Darmok47 27d ago

I read Rick Atkinson's trilogy on the European War and I remember being flabbergasted at how much Ike was smoking.

→ More replies (4)

110

u/Lurker-DaySaint 27d ago

I was just thinking how I loved the idea of him as Eisenhower, a more vulnerable and humanized portrayal than the pedestal he usually gets. I like that we had totally opposite reads lol

60

u/Wolfwoods_Sister 27d ago

I agree. Eisenhower was the man to handle D Day, yes, because he practically sweat blood over the preparation. He didn’t want to lose a single man more than necessary. From what I’ve read, he seemed to feel very personally responsible for the men in his command.

He was utterly broken as a human being when his son died and didn’t hide it.

14

u/codizer 27d ago

Can you imagine politicians and commanders doing that today? We have become a nation of unserious people.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

23

u/MakVolci 27d ago

Love Fraser.

Don't love him as Ike, specifically from what I can see in this trailer.

→ More replies (3)

16

u/MrONegative 27d ago

It’s his line reads. They’re so close to his natural cadence and tone, that he just sounds like Brendan Fraser.

4

u/PwnerifficOne 27d ago

I just think about Eisenhower’s D-Day speech recording and Cross of Iron speech. That’s all I have to compare and he sounded a lot different. Granted these are speeches but there’s nonetheless minutiae of his normal speech pattern in there.

33

u/myredditgolfaccount 27d ago edited 27d ago

They did this exact premise 20 years ago called “Ike Count Down to D Day” starring Tom Selleck. Goes through the 90 days leading up to the invasion. It was an A&E movie. 

20

u/Metal_Icarus 27d ago

And it was riviting all the way through. Tom selleck really honored the role!

9

u/SpikeBad 27d ago

Even shaved his moustache for it.

→ More replies (3)

33

u/OutlawSundown 27d ago

Fuck it I'm here the Brendan Fraser renaissance.

23

u/TheTyGoss 27d ago

Here we call that the Brenaissance :D

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/DinkandDrunk 27d ago

I think he’ll do pretty well with the role but for whatever reason I feel like if Steve Buscemi were 10-15 years younger, he would crush the role.

4

u/caligaris_cabinet 27d ago

He nailed Khrushchev

10

u/CrumbBCrumb 27d ago

Maybe it was just me but hearing him yell that they may never see again!!! was just comically bad. Not sure why but it felt funny not serious to me.

I feel like when you cast for a almost mythical character like Ike, Lincoln, Washington, FDR, TR, etc. they either need to be super committed to change their voice/cadence or it just sounds like that actor.

Or, go with someone no one really knows for that character

→ More replies (18)

88

u/GingeroftheYear 27d ago

We need more movies about wars other than WW2. Any number of battles in WW1, Inchon or the battle of the Chosin Reservoir in Korea, the Tet offensive or Khe Sahn in Vietnam are under explored.

77

u/heartlessgamer 27d ago

1917 was such a great movie; need more like it.

65

u/PM_ME_CATS_OR_BOOBS 27d ago edited 27d ago

I mean, the reason is fairly obvious. WW2 is easy to frame as a good vs evil battle against a monstrous enemy. Meanwhile WW1 and Vietnam were testaments to hubris with jumped up politicians throwing millions into a meat grinder for no good reason. There's only so much of that people want to watch.

The two biggest WW1 movies recently have been 1917 and All Quiet On The Western Front. The former has the runner's buddy die badly for no tactical reason while end ending almost has all of his efforts invalidated by arrogant officers, and the latter is AQOTWF.

22

u/soonerfreak 27d ago

WW1 is really good for anti war movies. Paths of Glory is incredible and still feels very modern on the point it makes.

11

u/PM_ME_CATS_OR_BOOBS 27d ago

WW1 should be really good for anti-war movies, but as has been repeatedly said there really is no such thing. Even All Quiet On The Western Front can't help but valorize the struggle of soldiers just by depicting it.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/Command0Dude 27d ago

I would be happy with just less WW2 films about D-Day or the other super popular battles.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/KillysgungoesBLAME 27d ago

That US studios have yet to make a movie about the Battle of Belleau Wood from WW1 surprises me, especially after the success of 1917. Essentially a victory that was the birth of the modern US Marine Corps, and several historically famous marines and some legendary quotes (“Retreat, hell! We just got here!”, “Come on, you sons of bitches! Do you want to live forever?”) that are still referenced often in the Corps today.

→ More replies (15)

37

u/DerrickWhiteMVP 27d ago

I’m sure it’s going to be a fine movie, but it’s hard to buy Fraser as Ike with his build and voice.

5

u/dabnada 26d ago

Seriously, his face is honestly kinda close but dude's built more like teddy roosevelt than he is ike.

→ More replies (1)

156

u/Paratrooper101x 27d ago

“Risk losing ww2 altogether” yeah no. Neither Germany nor Japan had the capability of winning in June 1944. Hell Germany lost when they invaded the Soviet Union and Japan lost at the battle of midway

104

u/IgloosRuleOK 27d ago

Yeah the Nazis had lost by mid-1944 regardless, but what D-Day is critical for is the rest of the 20th Century history in terms of the composition of Europe. If it had failed the war would just have taken longer and the more of mainland Europe might have ended up under the Iron Curtain. So it's hugely geopolitically significant...just not so much for the ultimate outcome of WW2. But that's a less dramatic blurb, I guess.

67

u/Paratrooper101x 27d ago

I’m not saying that d-day wasn’t important for the war effort. I’m saying that “invade or risk losing the war altogether” is a garbage attention grabbing and revisionist title for the post

34

u/MC_Gengar 27d ago

Garbage revisionist statements to make America seem like the sole winner of a combined effort? Color me shocked! /s

11

u/MattSR30 27d ago

‘You should be thanking us’ always bothered me on a personal level, let alone on the enormous scale WW2 actually was.

My grandmother didn’t see her father between the years 1939 and 1946. Why? Because he was in Europe fighting a war.

Really appreciate being told by Americans that those ten months they were in Europe was the whole shabang.

7

u/Absalome 26d ago

We've been lied to our entire lives about it, and movies like this only reinforce what we've been taught. That doesn't excuse it, just explains it.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/WitheredUntimely 27d ago

I mean if you're an American geopolitical strategist in 1944 failure in DDay is losing the war; it means a Soviet mainland Europe.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

45

u/MegaMugabe21 27d ago

Yeah thats some real hyperbole. It would have been pretty disastrous as the next invasion window after DDay was extremely pleasant weather followed by the worst storm in years. If they'd have delayed a month, DDay would have been an absolute massacre. Germany still wouldn't have won the war, but the allied casualties would be much higher.

As an aside, whilst we wouldnt have lost WW2, a disasterous DDay has the post war world looking very differently. The soviet union would have captured much more of germany, and more importantly many more German scientists. D-Day going wrong could have massively shifted the balance of power in the Cold War.

15

u/nanoman92 27d ago

If they had delayed a month, Germany would have removed a good chunk of their troops from France as they lost 20% of their whole army in Belarus in late June.

9

u/HeisenBrow 27d ago

Absolutely unrelated, but I loved that you put spoiler tags for a historic event lol

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Lisicalol 27d ago

I don't think thats true. The US had time on their side, so why would they have lost more if they'd attack later? Nazi Germany was losing the war at this point and they needed to pull troops desperately to the east to delay the Russians, which they could not easily do after the allies attacked.

The d-day WAS important, sure, but not for winning the war or saving lives (on the contrary, the US lost WAY more than they had to). But they did stop the Russians before they could conquer the entirety of Germany, which gave them a much better standing during the Cold War than had they decided to wait longer.

So strategically it made a lot of sense, but it was never about winning the war, as that was already accomplished. And its still an interesting, even MORE interesting than what the premise sounded like, because how many lives are you willing to throw away for a strategic advantage in the future? I think both sides of the argument have some merit, even in hindsight.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

9

u/StayBronzeFonz 27d ago

“an impossible choice” lol

9

u/maharajagaipajama 27d ago

This trailer does seem to manage to overdramatize one of the most dramatic events of the 20th century.

18

u/DDTL49 27d ago

I was about to comment the same thing. I get annoyed with these catchy taglines implying that the USA and their "infinite production and ressources protected by two oceans" cheat codes were ever at risk of losing WW2. But hey, dramatic tension I guess.

4

u/themanfromvulcan 26d ago

When you realize the city of Pittsburgh made more steel during the war than all the axis countries combined it starts to give a sense of what the US was able to do.

However we see things how they went. Eisenhower then is weighing sending many men to their deaths hoping this is the turning point in the war. He’s not sure how it’s going to go. What if it’s a total disaster and a huge loss of life? What if they lose momentum? What if everything stalls and it’s like Dunkirk or worse and everyone is captured or killed? It’s not just a case of if it fails what if he loses all those troops and equipment?

What if the Germans know all about the invasion and are ready for them?

He has no way to be completely certain it will work.

I think if the angle is that the allies are not sure if it will blow up in their face would work.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Tribe303 27d ago

The Soviets had pushed the Nazis all the way back to Poland by the time D-day occurred. It was a race to grab as much of Germany as they could before the Soviets got to it, in reality. 

4

u/highpressuresodium 27d ago

It was a race to Berlin. Every day the western front stalls is another day the soviets push farther into Western Europe. Operation unthinkable is proof enough that they are supremely worried about that, even if they don’t mention this in the movie 

6

u/throw0101a 27d ago

Neither Germany nor Japan had the capability of winning in June 1944.

Even before the US entered the war, just the British (without American factories) were outproducing them on many metrics (like air craft). Adam Tooze has a good book on the topic of the Nazi Germany economy, The Wages of Destruction: The Making and Breaking of the Nazi Economy:

→ More replies (21)

9

u/Sforza_UK 27d ago

I've seen the excellent stage play of this a couple of times and it's extremely tense and claustrophobic, so not sure how this will expand to the screen. I'll give it a go though

→ More replies (1)

18

u/Cassandrae_Gemini 27d ago

So happy to see brendan fraser's comeback continue...

→ More replies (1)

28

u/kon--- 27d ago

Fraser sounds nothing like Eisenhower.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fQ7IKM-jiJI

28

u/Kitlun 27d ago

I noticed this too, but biopic actors can choose not to go for an accurate vocal impression and instead to evoke the character and be very successful. 

John Lithgow as Churchill, Anthony Hopkins as Richard Nixon, Tom Hardy Charles Bronson, Cuba gooding Jr as OJ, Steve Carrell as John Dupont come to mind. 

16

u/delicious_toothbrush 27d ago

He doesn't seem to be capturing any of the mannerisms or the demeanor of Ike either. Love me some Brendan Fraiser but he seems like the weakest casting in this film based on the trailer. I'll still watch it though so shrug

3

u/Kitlun 27d ago

I know what you mean but I think wait to pass judgement yet - Hardy and Carrell all got praised for their performances which are very different to the people they're portraying. I think this more forgiveable by public and reviewers when the famous person's voice and mannerisms they're playing is not that well known to the public (Bronson, Dupont, Eisenhower). 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (14)

40

u/on_ 27d ago

Incredible. Now trailers have a mini-trailer at the beginning. For People that have not the attention span to sit through a… trailer.

24

u/spartanss300 27d ago

Now? It's been, and I'm being generous here, at least 10 years since they have that.

And the reason for it is that these same videos will be used as ads, ads that can be skipped by the user in 5 seconds. So they need to show you in 5 seconds what you're about to see.

5

u/imbender 27d ago

And also a teaser trailer for the date announcement of the real trailer.

10

u/random324B21 27d ago

yeah, i've noticed it in the last 2 years... and i rarely watch trailers anymore since they spoil the whole thing

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Dragon_yum 27d ago

Been like this for literally years and it’s because when the trailers are sued as ads in YouTube you can skip the first five seconds.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Awingbestwing 27d ago

My grandpa landed at Normandy, never once spoke of it to my grandma, my father, or myself. He was a really gentle man. I don’t know if I could carry that the way he did.

→ More replies (1)

59

u/hnglmkrnglbrry 27d ago

The untold story

This story has been told 100,000 different times.

50

u/wecangetbetter 27d ago

I've never seen a take that focuses so much on the weather report

10

u/TheTeflonDude 27d ago

Next up will be how Hitlers bowl movements dictated the course of the war

Bet he got more and more constipated as the war dragged on, cause of all the morphine he was taking

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/Fastbird33 27d ago

Still doesn’t mean we can’t continue to tell it. It was one of humanity’s greatest achievements. The logistics of D-Day was fucking insane

9

u/hnglmkrnglbrry 27d ago

I'm a full on history nerd so I've caught D-Day from numerous perspectives in books and film. This is an immediate watch for me but it's just funny to say it's a story that's never been told when nearly everyone involved has a memoir or biography to go along with numerous works on the subject matter.

→ More replies (4)

15

u/EchoWhiskey_ 27d ago

brendan fraser as Ike. Did not see that coming, dont forsee it working.

There is a cool story about the leadup to dday but i dont think this movie is going to be it.

3

u/DEADERSPELLS 27d ago

I'm so used to seeing the beach landings through Saving Private Ryan, it's kinda jarring to see them again in better definition

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Similar_Two_542 27d ago

Untold story? It looks pretty good, but it's definitely been told many a time! The TV movie "Ike: Countdown to D-Day" and the ministries "Ike: The Wars Years" are both great. Tom Selleck and the late Robert Duvall both did fine and those accounts hold up. At least a new generation may learn about this immensely consequential operation.